top of page

Efficacy Is Conscious Agency

8 hours ago
3 min read

Wed 18-NOV-26


Efficacy is conscious agency.


It’s being aware of the role you play and the scope—the space and context in which you have to act—then using that capacity effectively and with intention.


In The Society of Mind, the cognitive scientist Marvin Minsky explores what’s really happening in the mind when we’re thinking deeply or carrying out everyday, ordinary, common activities.


The Society of Mind by Marvin Minsky, book cover


In one example, Minsky asks us to imagine what it takes to build a tower out of blocks. He gives one process the name Builder. It looks like one thing that knows how to build a tower. But look a little closer…. It’s not really one thing. It’s many things acting together. Something has to find a block. Something has to grasp it. Something has to move it; and something has to put it in place.


Builder clipart from the video: a person and blocks for building a tower

An agent is a thing that does a particular part of the work.


An agency, in Minsky’s sense, is an assembly of parts understood by what they can accomplish together.


So if I want to understand how this tower gets built, I have to look at what the parts do and how they work together.


Builder agency diagram: Begin, Add and End, with Find, Get, Put, Grasp and Move

And I can change the scale. Builder is an agency when I look at everything that goes into building the tower. If I pull back and look at what the mind is doing as a whole, Builder is one agent within that larger activity.


Minsky’s diagram showing Builder alongside other agents within the mind. Builder branches into Find, Get, and Put.

What I see depends on where I’m looking from and what I’m trying to understand.


So let’s take that way of looking at things and apply it to schooling.


The One Best System by David B. Tyack, book cover


“Effective reform today will require reassessment of some cherished convictions about the possibility of finding a one best system, about the value of insulating the school from community influence, about the irrelevance of ethnic differences. To succeed in improving the schooling of the dispossessed, educators are increasingly realizing that they need to share power over educational decision-making with representatives of urban communities they serve, that they need to find ways to teach that match the learning styles of the many ethnic groups, that they need to develop many alternatives within the system….”

David Tyack wrote these words in a book first published more than 50 years ago. It said then what we still know today:


If we’re going to talk about how all the parts of a school system work together, we have to ask what we want them to accomplish together.


Here’s the purpose I want schools to work from.


Create fair opportunities for everyone to learn.


At the level of the system, there are decisions about how resources are distributed. At the level of the school, there are decisions about how people and time are organized. And at the level of the classroom, there’s a teacher asking, How do I create that opportunity for the students I’m actually teaching?


This is an ethical responsibility of teaching. You’re acting inside a school, and that school is part of a system. Both shape the conditions in which you teach. And within those conditions, there’s a question of agency. The teacher’s agency to act on their experience in the classroom to create fair opportunities for every student to learn. Teachers have a responsibility to be agents. And teachers have a responsibility to act with agency.


I think the most powerful act of teacher agency comes in the acts of planning.


That’s where you’re considering the concepts to be understood, the minds you’re engaging with, and the purpose for the craft.


What do I want these students to understand? What do I know about them that helps me see a way into that understanding? And what can I do, within the scope I have to act, to give more of them a fair opportunity to engage in rigorous thinking?


That’s what I mean when I say Teacher Smart is the thoughtful implementation of agency.


There’s a conscious intention in the decisions we make about what our students will have the opportunity to think about and do.


Efficacy is conscious agency. It’s being aware of the role you play and the scope you have to act, then using that capacity effectively and with intention.

 
 
bottom of page